Home › Blog › UK safeguarding

Qualified or adverse safeguarding audit report: what happens next and how to respond

By Harry Khan, Founder · Published 16 November 2026 · Last reviewed 16 November 2026

Summary
  • The safeguarding report carries two opinions: on the firm's systems throughout the period and on its compliance at the period end. Either can be unmodified, qualified or adverse, and the auditor can say it is unable to form an opinion.
  • The breaches schedule lists every breach found in the period, so a clean opinion can still come with breaches.
  • The auditor must give the firm a draft. The firm's explanation of each breach and its remedial action is written into the report the FCA receives.
  • The auditor, not the firm, sends the final report to the FCA, and the firm must report it to its governing body.
  • Matters such as a reconciliation that could not be performed must be notified to the FCA without delay under CASS 15.8.60R; they cannot wait for the audit.

The possible outcomes

Under SUP 3A.9.2R the auditor states two things: whether the firm maintained systems adequate to comply with the relevant funds regime throughout the period, and whether it complied at the end of the period. Each opinion can take one of these forms.

OutcomeWhat it meansRule
UnmodifiedThe requirement was met. Breaches may still be listed in the breaches scheduleSUP 3A.9.2R, 3A.9.12R
QualifiedThe requirement was met except in specified respects, which the report must set outSUP 3A.9.11R
AdverseThe requirement was not met, with each respect specifiedSUP 3A.9.11R
Unable to form an opinionThe auditor could not obtain enough evidence; the report states which requirements and whySUP 3A.9.15R

Where no breach was found, the report must say so (SUP 3A.9.12R(2)). The FRC's Appendix 13 exposure draft includes illustrative qualified, adverse and unmodified reports in the format the FCA prescribes in SUP 3A Annex 1.

How the auditor decides

The FCA expects the auditor to use professional judgement on the significance of each breach, its context, how long it lasted and whether it was repeated, and to consider the aggregate effect of breaches when deciding whether a requirement was met (SUP 3A.9.14G(2)). Several minor breaches of the same kind can add up to a qualification; one short breach that was found and corrected quickly may not.

That is why the breach log matters as much as the breaches. A log that shows when each breach was found, how fast it was fixed and what changed afterwards gives the auditor the context the guidance asks it to weigh.

The draft report: the firm's chance to respond

The auditor must give the firm a draft with enough time to consider the findings (SUP 3A.9.10R). The FCA expects the firm to explain, for each breach, the circumstances that caused it and the remedial action taken or planned, and to send that explanation to the auditor before the report is due, recorded in the field provided in the draft (SUP 3A.10.1G). The auditor must include it (SUP 3A.9.5R). If it arrives too late, the report goes to the FCA without it, with a note explaining why.

StepWhoWhen
Draft report with findingsAuditor to firmBefore the deadline, with adequate time to respond
Explanation and remedial actions for each breachFirm to auditorPromptly, and before the report is due
Final reportAuditor to the FCA, copy to the firm at the same timeWithin four months of the period end (six months for the first report where the period ends within 12 months of 7 May 2026)
Report to the governing bodyFirmOn receipt of the final report (SUP 3A.10.2R)

Write each explanation as a supervisor would want to read it: what happened, the root cause, the customer impact, the fix, the date it was fixed and how the firm will know it has not recurred.

What happens after the report reaches the FCA

The FCA uses the report in its supervision of the firm, and expects the firm to use it to evaluate its own systems and build it into its risk management and decisions (SUP 3A.10.3G). After a qualified or adverse opinion, a firm should expect questions from its supervisor and should have its remediation plan ready before they arrive.

The FCA has wider tools. The rules confirm, for example, that an auditor must help any skilled person appointed by the firm or the FCA under section 166 of FSMA, as applied to payment and e-money firms (SUP 3A.8.4R). A firm with a serious or repeated failure should plan on the basis that the FCA may want independent confirmation that the remediation has worked.

Separately, statutory auditors must report matters of material significance to the FCA, and the FCA says a failure to safeguard will usually be one (SUP 3A.8.10G).

What cannot wait for the audit

Some events must be notified to the FCA in writing without delay under CASS 15.8.60R, whatever the audit timetable: records that are materially out of date or inaccurate, a reconciliation that cannot be performed or materially fails, a shortfall that cannot be paid in, discrepancies that cannot be resolved, and a material difference in the preceding 12 months between what was safeguarded and what should have been. A breach the auditor finds that should already have been notified is a second problem on top of the first.

The FCA also says a firm should consider whether to notify it under Principle 11 when it receives a written communication from its auditor about internal controls (SUP 3A.7.1G).

A response plan

  1. Before the draft: keep the breach log current, with cause, duration and fix for each entry.
  2. On the draft: agree the facts with the auditor, then write each explanation and remedial action, signed off by the director or senior manager responsible for safeguarding.
  3. On the final report: take it to the board, approve a remediation plan with owners and dates, and decide what to tell the FCA and when.
  4. During remediation: test each fix, keep evidence, and report progress to the board.
  5. For the next period: run a readiness review well before the period ends, so the same findings do not appear twice.

Changing auditor does not remove a finding: an auditor removed from office or resigning must notify the FCA (SUP 3A.8.11R), and the FCA expects firms to keep their auditor's adequacy under review on its merits (SUP 3A.10.4G).

How Buckingham Capital Consulting helps

We help firms respond to a draft or final safeguarding report: the breach explanations, the remediation plan, the board paper and the evidence that each fix works. Before the next period ends, our safeguarding audit readiness review tests the same areas the auditor will. See also our safeguarding services and the safeguarding audit checklist.

Questions

What is a qualified safeguarding audit opinion?

An opinion that the firm met a requirement except in specified respects. Under SUP 3A.9.11R the report must set out each requirement not met and the respects in which it was not met.

Who sends the safeguarding audit report to the FCA?

The auditor, by the FCA's electronic means (SUP 3A.9.16R), within four months of the period end, or six months for a first period ending within 12 months of 7 May 2026. The firm receives a copy at the same time.

Can the firm comment on the safeguarding audit report?

Yes. The auditor must provide a draft, and the FCA expects the firm to give an explanation of each breach and its remedial actions, which the auditor must include in the report (SUP 3A.9.10R, 3A.10.1G, 3A.9.5R).

Can a clean safeguarding audit report still list breaches?

Yes. The breaches schedule lists every breach identified in the period, even where the auditor concludes the requirements were met.

What if the auditor cannot form an opinion?

The report must specify the requirements on which no opinion could be formed and the reasons (SUP 3A.9.15R).

Sources

Get in touch: +44 7563 115980 (phone and WhatsApp) or [email protected].

This article is general information, not legal advice. Requirements change, and the regulator’s own publications take precedence.

Get in touch

Tell us where you are and where you want to be.

[email protected]
+44 7563 115980 (phone and WhatsApp)