Home › Blog › UK safeguarding

Safeguarding audit checklist: the evidence your CASS 15 auditor will ask for

By Harry Khan, Founder · Published 16 November 2026 · Last reviewed 16 November 2026

Summary
  • The safeguarding auditor gives two opinions under SUP 3A.9.2R: whether the firm's systems were adequate to comply throughout the period, and whether it complied at the period end.
  • The work is a reasonable assurance engagement, and the breaches schedule must list every breach of a safeguarding rule found in the period, whatever its size.
  • Internal and external safeguarding reconciliations are required each reconciliation day under CASS 15.8.19R and CASS 15.8.42R, and they are the core of the auditor's testing.
  • A firm whose first audit period ends on 31 December 2026 must have the report with the FCA by 30 June 2027; later reports are due within four months.
  • Evidence has to exist for the whole period. A gap in March cannot be fixed in December, so the time to check is before the period ends.

What the safeguarding auditor gives an opinion on

Under SUP 3A.9.2R the auditor's report to the FCA states whether, in the auditor's opinion, the firm maintained systems adequate to comply with the relevant funds regime throughout the period, and whether it was in compliance at the end of the period. The report is prepared as a reasonable assurance engagement, the same level of assurance as a financial statement audit, so the auditor tests evidence rather than reading policies.

Every breach the auditor identifies goes into the breaches schedule, whether it found the breach itself or the firm disclosed it (SUP 3A.9.12R and SUP 3A.9.14G). A clean opinion can still come with a list of breaches. Our full guide to the CASS 15 safeguarding audit covers scope, deadlines and the report format.

The checklist

Each line is something the auditor will ask to see, with the rule it tests. Have it for the whole audit period, not only the period end.

AreaEvidence to have readyRule
Business model and funds flowA current description of how money comes in, where it sits and how it leaves, for every product and corridorCASS 15.2
Identifying relevant fundsRecords showing each receipt of relevant funds allocated to an individual client no later than the end of the next business day, and when it was segregated, including funds received through agents and distributorsCASS 15.2.5R, CASS 15.3
RecordsRecords that let the firm tell relevant funds apart from its own money at any time and without delayCASS 15.8
Internal reconciliationsA completed internal safeguarding reconciliation for each reconciliation day, with sign-off and an explanation for every differenceCASS 15.8.19R
External reconciliationsA completed external reconciliation against bank and custodian records for each reconciliation dayCASS 15.8.42R
Shortfalls and excessesProof each shortfall was paid in and each excess withdrawn, with datesCASS 15.8.50R, 15.8.51R
Reconciliation methodConfirmation that the standard method is used, or the auditor's report on a non-standard methodCASS 15.8.36R
Banks, custodians and insurersSelection and periodic review records for each third party holding relevant funds or providing coverCASS 15.6
Acknowledgement lettersA signed letter in force for every safeguarding account at the period endCASS 15.7
NotificationsCopies of any notifications made to the FCA, for example a reconciliation that could not be performedCASS 15.8.60R
Monthly returnEach monthly safeguarding return, agreed to the underlying recordsSUP 16.14A
Resolution packA pack that could be handed to an insolvency practitioner and retrieved within the required timeCASS 10A
GovernanceThe single director or senior manager responsible for safeguarding oversight, their reports to the board, minutes and management informationCASS 15.2
Systems and outsourcingEvidence on IT general controls behind system-generated reconciliations, and on outsourced providers that calculate or hold relevant fundsFRC guidance
Breach logEvery breach in the period, its cause, its duration and what was done about itSUP 3A.9.12R, 3A.10.1G

The detail behind several lines is in our guides to safeguarding reconciliations, the monthly safeguarding return and the CASS 10A resolution pack.

What auditors test at the period end

The FRC's exposure draft of Appendix 13 to the CASS Assurance Standard, published for consultation on 30 September 2026, lists the kind of period-end work auditors are expected to do. It includes:

  • testing internal and external safeguarding reconciliations at the period end date and whether explanations of reconciling items are legitimate;
  • obtaining external confirmation letters or other direct evidence from banks and custodians;
  • checking that acknowledgement letters have been obtained and are in force at the period end; and
  • examining contractual terms with third parties.

The draft also asks auditors to adopt an insolvency mind-set: to test whether the firm's records would let relevant funds be identified at any time and without delay if the firm failed. A record that works day to day but would not stand up in an insolvency is a finding.

Gaps to look for before the auditor does

GapWhy it matters
Reconciliations performed but not signed off, or differences without explanationThe auditor tests the explanation, not just the existence of the reconciliation
An acknowledgement letter missing for one account, often a newer or currency accountTested at the period end; one missing letter is a breach
A breach log that only lists large breachesThe breaches schedule must include every breach found in the period
Monthly returns that do not agree to the reconciliationsInconsistency between returns and records is easy for the auditor to test
No evidence on the system that produces reconciliationsThe auditor may need to test IT controls before relying on system output
A funds flow description that leaves out a newer productRelevant funds outside the description may not have been identified or segregated

Our free safeguarding readiness checker gives a first view in a few minutes.

When the first report is due

The audit period must end no more than 53 weeks after the firm first became subject to SUP 3A (SUP 3A.9.6R). The auditor delivers the report to the FCA within four months of the period end (SUP 3A.9.7R), with six months allowed for the first report where the period ends within 12 months of 7 May 2026.

Audit period endsReport to the FCA by
31 December 2026 (first period)30 June 2027
31 March 2027 (first period)30 September 2027
Any later periodFour months after the period end

The auditor sends a draft first, and the firm records its explanation of each breach and the remedial action in the draft (SUP 3A.10.1G). Leave time for that step: it is the firm's only chance to put its side in the report the FCA reads.

How Buckingham Capital Consulting helps

We run a safeguarding audit readiness review against this checklist before the period ends: we test a sample of reconciliations, letters, returns and breach records the way an auditor would, list each gap with the rule it breaches, and help fix what can still be fixed in the period. The auditor gives the opinion; we make sure the evidence is there when they look.

Questions

What does a safeguarding auditor check?

Whether the firm's systems were adequate to comply with the safeguarding rules throughout the period and whether it complied at the period end (SUP 3A.9.2R). In practice that means testing reconciliations, records, acknowledgement letters, third-party arrangements, notifications, returns, governance and the breach log.

Is the safeguarding audit reasonable or limited assurance?

Reasonable assurance. SUP 3A.9.1R requires the report to be prepared in accordance with the terms of a reasonable assurance engagement.

Do small breaches go in the safeguarding audit report?

Yes. The breaches schedule must identify each rule breached, and the FCA expects it to include every breach identified in the period, whether found by the auditor or disclosed by the firm (SUP 3A.9.12R and SUP 3A.9.14G).

How often must safeguarding reconciliations be done?

Internal and external safeguarding reconciliations must each be performed at least once each reconciliation day (CASS 15.8.19R and CASS 15.8.42R).

When is the first safeguarding audit report due?

Within six months of the end of the first audit period where that period ends within 12 months of 7 May 2026, so 30 June 2027 for a period ending 31 December 2026. Later reports are due within four months.

Sources

Get in touch: +44 7563 115980 (phone and WhatsApp) or [email protected].

This article is general information, not legal advice. Requirements change, and the regulator’s own publications take precedence.

Get in touch

Tell us where you are and where you want to be.

[email protected]
+44 7563 115980 (phone and WhatsApp)