[email protected]
+44 7563 115980 (phone and WhatsApp)
An independent ranking, updated monthly, of the audit firms that carry out the FCA's annual safeguarding audit for payment and e-money institutions. 13 firms, six criteria, nothing paid for.
Scores out of 100, weighted as set out in the method below. Facts read on 16 November 2026 from each firm's own pages and the Register of Statutory Auditors.
| Rank and provider | Score /100 | Status | Strongest for |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Moore Kingston Smith | 91 | Audit firm with a safeguarding audit service | Firms wanting a clear, published audit approach and timetable |
| 2. Johnston Carmichael | 82 | Audit firm with a dedicated CASS and safeguarding audit team | Firms wanting a CASS specialist team with IT audit support |
| 3. BDO | 77 | Audit firm with a Head of Safeguarding | Larger payment and e-money firms wanting a national firm with a named safeguarding lead |
| 4. BKL | 76 | Audit firm with a CASS 15 hub | Smaller and growing e-money firms |
| 5. Buzzacott | 76 | Audit firm with a safeguarding audit service | Payment and e-money firms wanting a dedicated safeguarding team |
| 6. Price Bailey | 74 | Audit firm with a CASS and safeguarding audit service | Firms wanting a published step-by-step process |
| 7. PKF Littlejohn | 69 | Audit firm with a payment services team | Payment and e-money firms wanting detailed audit guidance |
| 8. Grant Thornton | 58 | Audit firm with payments advisory and assurance | Larger firms wanting a national firm with CASS depth |
| 9. KPMG | 52 | Audit firm with a CASS consulting team | Large firms wanting readiness work and mock audits |
| 10. Crowe | 46 | Audit firm | Firms already using Crowe for their statutory audit |
| 11. Saffery | 43 | Audit firm | Firms wanting a mid-sized firm with a financial services practice |
| 12. MAH | 37 | Audit firm | Smaller fintech firms |
| 13. Wellers | 32 | Audit firm | Small firms checking whether they need an audit |
Every award follows from the published scores: Leader for the top three overall, and Top rated for any firm scoring 5 out of 5 on a criterion. Awards cannot be bought.
Moore Kingston Smith, Johnston Carmichael, BKL, Buzzacott, Price Bailey
Moore Kingston Smith, Johnston Carmichael, BDO, BKL, Buzzacott
Winners may show the badge on their own website, linked to this page; using an award in advertising is part of Membership, which never affects a score.
Scores out of 5 are the overall score out of 100 divided by 20. Badge terms and Membership
Each criterion is scored 0 to 5 against the scale in the method. 0 means not published.
| Provider | Safeguarding audit service | Payments and e-money depth | Standing | Current knowledge | Clarity of process | Scale |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Moore Kingston Smith | 5 | 5 | 3 | 5 | 5 | 4 |
| Johnston Carmichael | 5 | 5 | 5 | 3 | 3 | 3 |
| BDO | 3 | 5 | 4 | 5 | 1 | 5 |
| BKL | 5 | 5 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 2 |
| Buzzacott | 5 | 5 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 2 |
| Price Bailey | 5 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 5 | 2 |
| PKF Littlejohn | 3 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 3 | 3 |
| Grant Thornton | 1 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 0 | 5 |
| KPMG | 1 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 0 | 5 |
| Crowe | 1 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 0 | 4 |
| Saffery | 1 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 0 | 3 |
| MAH | 3 | 1 | 3 | 3 | 0 | 1 |
| Wellers | 1 | 1 | 3 | 3 | 1 | 1 |
6 criteria, scored only from what each firm publishes and the public register.
Whether the firm publishes a page describing the SUP 3A safeguarding audit it carries out for payment and e-money firms.
A payments and e-money sector team, with a named partner or lead for safeguarding.
Registration on the Register of Statutory Auditors, and published client asset (CASS) audit experience.
Published guidance on the new safeguarding rules (PS25/12 and CASS 15) and on the FRC's interim guidance for safeguarding auditors.
A published audit approach: stages, what the firm must provide and when to start.
Statutory auditors and offices linked to the firm on the Register of Statutory Auditors.
| Criterion | Weight |
|---|---|
| Safeguarding audit service | 20 |
| Payments and e-money depth | 20 |
| Standing | 15 |
| Current knowledge | 15 |
| Clarity of process | 15 |
| Scale | 15 |
| Criterion | 5 | 3 | 0 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Safeguarding audit service | Dedicated page for the safeguarding audit | Safeguarding audits offered on a sector page or in an article | Not published |
| Payments and e-money depth | Payments or safeguarding team with a named partner or lead | Financial services team or a named contact, not payments-specific | Not published |
| Standing | On the register, with CASS audit work beyond safeguarding published | On the register | Not on the register |
| Current knowledge | Guidance on CASS 15 and on the FRC's interim guidance | Guidance on one of the two | Not published |
| Clarity of process | Stages, information needed and timing published | Some description of the approach | Not published |
| Scale | 100 or more statutory auditors on the register (4: 50 to 99; 2: 10 to 24; 1: under 10) | 25 to 49 statutory auditors | Not on the register |
Score out of 100 is the sum of each criterion score divided by five and multiplied by its weight. Ties are broken by the safeguarding audit service, then payments and e-money depth.
What each firm publishes, criterion by criterion, with the date read and the source.
A dedicated safeguarding audit page for payment and e-money firms setting out what is tested, from reconciliations to agents and banks, and an opinion in a format for FCA submission. It publishes guidance on CASS 15 and the FRC's interim guidance, and a payment services and e-money sector page.
Firms wanting a clear, published audit approach and timetable.
| Safeguarding audit service | Dedicated page: "Safeguarding audit services for payment and e-money firms". "We provide a clear, actionable opinion in a format suitable for FCA submission." |
| Payments team | Payment services and e-money sector page. Named contact: Tom Moore, "Partner, Head of Financial Services". |
| Published guidance | "Key takeaways for safeguarding audits: CASS 15 and the FRC's interim guidance". |
| Process | Tests "the timeliness, accuracy and completeness of your reconciliation processes"; reviews policy, resolution pack, record keeping, governance, agents, distributors and banks; advises "starting your safeguarding audit engagement at least two months before your deadline". |
| Register | Moore Kingston Smith LLP: registered by ICAEW; 75 statutory auditors and 9 offices linked on the Register of Statutory Auditors, updated 12 November 2026. |
| Date read | Read 16 November 2026 |
A dedicated CASS audit team covering client money, custody assets and CASS 15 safeguarding audits for payment and e-money firms, led by a named Head of CASS and Safeguarding, with CASS and IT audit specialists working together.
Firms wanting a CASS specialist team with IT audit support.
| Safeguarding audit service | CASS audit services page: "CASS and safeguarding audits" across "CASS 6 (custody assets), CASS 7 (client money) and safeguarding requirements for payment and e-money firms (CASS 15)". |
| Payments team | Gillian Boston, "Head of CASS & Safeguarding"; "we have invested in building a dedicated CASS audit team". |
| Published guidance | "CASS 15: payment services and e-money" insight and a CASS 15 safeguarding webinar. |
| Process | "We support clients through the audit process by providing clarity on the information requested, the nature of our testing and the regulatory purpose behind it"; CASS and IT audit specialists assess systems and data flows. |
| Register | Johnston Carmichael LLP: registered by ICAS; 29 statutory auditors and 12 offices linked on the Register of Statutory Auditors, updated 12 November 2026. |
| Date read | Read 16 November 2026 |
Provides audit and assurance to the payments and e-money sector, with a named Partner, Head of Safeguarding, and detailed published guidance on the FRC's interim guidance for safeguarding auditors. It does not publish a dedicated safeguarding audit service page.
Larger payment and e-money firms wanting a national firm with a named safeguarding lead.
| Safeguarding audit service | "We provide audit and assurance, tax and advisory services to the Payments & E-money sector." No dedicated safeguarding audit service page found. |
| Payments team | Luke Patterson, "Partner, Head of Safeguarding". |
| Published guidance | "The FRC publishes its interim guidance to support safeguarding auditors during the transition to the FCA's new supplementary regime" and PS25/12 commentary. |
| Process | Not published for BDO's own engagements. |
| Register | BDO LLP: registered by ICAEW; 188 statutory auditors and 22 offices linked on the Register of Statutory Auditors, updated 12 November 2026. |
| Date read | Read 16 November 2026 |
A CASS 15 hub with named safeguarding audit specialists, a webinar on audit readiness and guidance on the resolution pack and breaches schedule, drawing on its experience auditing e-money institutions.
Smaller and growing e-money firms.
| Safeguarding audit service | CASS 15 hub: "Our specialists in safeguarding audits are here to ease the pressure". |
| Payments team | "Safeguarding audit specialists Jon Wedge, Alisha O'Donovan and Elana Dimmer"; "our years of experience working with and auditing EMIs". |
| Published guidance | CASS 15 hub with webinar, resolution pack and schedule of breaches guidance. |
| Process | Webinar on "practical steps to prepare for your first CASS 15 audit"; no engagement timetable. |
| Register | BKL Audit LLP: registered by ICAEW; 18 statutory auditors and 4 offices linked on the Register of Statutory Auditors, updated 12 November 2026. |
| Date read | Read 16 November 2026 |
A dedicated safeguarding audit page: a specialist team delivering reasonable assurance audits for payment and e-money institutions, with named partner and director contacts and guidance on PS25/12 and CASS 15 audit obligations.
Payment and e-money firms wanting a dedicated safeguarding team.
| Safeguarding audit service | "Our specialist safeguarding team delivers independent reasonable assurance audits for payment services and e-money institutions." |
| Payments team | Named contacts on the safeguarding page: Jonathan West, Partner, and Jay Patel, Director. |
| Published guidance | "CASS 15: What are my safeguarding audit obligations?" and PS25/12 commentary. |
| Process | Tests "the design and operating effectiveness of key controls"; describes the two opinions the report gives; no timetable. |
| Register | Buzzacott Audit LLP: registered by ICAEW; 17 statutory auditors and 2 offices linked on the Register of Statutory Auditors, updated 12 November 2026. |
| Date read | Read 16 November 2026 |
A dedicated CASS and safeguarding audit page offering annual CASS 15 safeguarding audits, with an established CASS audit capability and a published process from planning to the opinion.
Firms wanting a published step-by-step process.
| Safeguarding audit service | "We offer Annual safeguarding audits under CASS 15." |
| Payments team | "Dedicated specialists focused on regulated firms"; audit and assurance partners named, not tied to payments. |
| Published guidance | "Changes to the safeguarding regime for payment services and e-money firms" and "What is safeguarding and why does it matter". |
| Process | "We agree information request lists in advance"; planning and scoping, fieldwork and control testing, reporting and opinion; "Most work can be completed remotely." |
| Register | Price Bailey LLP: registered by ICAEW; 18 statutory auditors and 11 offices linked on the Register of Statutory Auditors, updated 12 November 2026. |
| Date read | Read 16 November 2026 |
A payment services and e-money team whose services include statutory audit and safeguarding work, with detailed guidance on the FRC's interim guidance, IT controls and preparing for a first CASS 15 audit.
Payment and e-money firms wanting detailed audit guidance.
| Safeguarding audit service | "Our specialist Payment Services team advise money remittance, payment processing and electronic money firms"; services include "statutory audit, financial reporting, regulatory advice and assurance, safeguard[ing]". |
| Payments team | Payment services and e-money sector page; no named payments audit partner on the pages read. |
| Published guidance | "FRC issues interim guidance for CASS 15 safeguarding audits"; "Preparing for your first CASS 15 audit". |
| Process | Guidance on what auditors will review, including IT general controls ("change management, user access and IT operations"). |
| Register | PKF Littlejohn LLP: registered by ICAEW; 33 statutory auditors and 3 offices linked on the Register of Statutory Auditors, updated 12 November 2026. |
| Date read | Read 16 November 2026 |
A payments advisory and assurance practice and published commentary on CASS 15 and the FRC's interim guidance. It does not publish a page describing its own safeguarding audit service.
Larger firms wanting a national firm with CASS depth.
| Safeguarding audit service | Article: "Auditors are also adapting their safeguarding audit approaches"; no safeguarding audit service page found. |
| Payments team | "Payments advisory and assurance" page with partner roles listed. |
| Published guidance | "CASS widens its net and raises the bar for everyone in scope", referring to CASS 15 and the FRC's interim guidance. |
| Process | Not published. |
| Register | Grant Thornton UK LLP: registered by ICAEW; 124 statutory auditors and 21 offices linked on the Register of Statutory Auditors, updated 12 November 2026. |
| Date read | Read 16 November 2026 |
A CASS team offering readiness assessments, mock CASS audits and training for payment firms preparing for CASS 15, with named CASS consulting directors. It does not publish a page describing a safeguarding audit service.
Large firms wanting readiness work and mock audits.
| Safeguarding audit service | "Preparing for CASS 15": gap analysis, readiness assessments and "mock CASS audits"; no safeguarding audit service page found. |
| Payments team | Hanish Arora and Rhoda Ejiga, "Director CASS Consulting". |
| Published guidance | "Preparing for CASS 15" (June 2025) and a PS25/12 panel event. |
| Process | Not published for a safeguarding audit. |
| Register | KPMG LLP: registered by ICAEW; 356 statutory auditors and 21 offices linked on the Register of Statutory Auditors, updated 12 November 2026. |
| Date read | Read 16 November 2026 |
Commentary on PS25/12 by its corporate audit team, with a named Head of Financial Services. It does not publish a page describing a safeguarding audit service.
Firms already using Crowe for their statutory audit.
| Safeguarding audit service | PS25/12 article refers to "qualified auditors, as required by the new regulations"; no safeguarding audit service page found. |
| Payments team | John Glasby, "Head of Financial Services"; author Mohsin Ejaz, "Director, Corporate Audit". |
| Published guidance | PS25/12 commentary, including the six-month first report deadline. |
| Process | Not published. |
| Register | Crowe U.K. LLP: registered by ICAEW; 56 statutory auditors and 9 offices linked on the Register of Statutory Auditors, updated 12 November 2026. |
| Date read | Read 16 November 2026 |
Detailed commentary on the new safeguarding rules and the SUP 3A audit, with a named London partner, and a financial services sector page. It does not publish a page describing its own safeguarding audit service.
Firms wanting a mid-sized firm with a financial services practice.
| Safeguarding audit service | Article on the new audit requirements; no safeguarding audit service page found. |
| Payments team | Financial services sector page; article contact Tom Alun-Jones, Partner, London. |
| Published guidance | "UK FCA safeguarding changes: new rules for e-money institutions and payment firms", covering CASS 10A, CASS 15, SUP 3A and SUP 16.14A. |
| Process | Not published. |
| Register | Saffery Audit (UK) LLP: registered by ICAEW; 44 statutory auditors and 10 offices linked on the Register of Statutory Auditors, updated 12 November 2026. |
| Date read | Read 16 November 2026 |
Offers "statutory safeguarding audits compliant with the new CASS 15 standards" and internal control advice for reconciliations, from an article on the new regime.
Smaller fintech firms.
| Safeguarding audit service | "Statutory safeguarding audits compliant with the new CASS 15 standards." |
| Payments team | "We specialise in helping FinTech and financial services firms"; no named lead. |
| Published guidance | "Changes to safeguarding for payments and e-money firms and CASS 15 audits". |
| Process | Not published. |
| Register | MAH Professional Services Limited: registered by ICAEW; 1 statutory auditors and 4 offices linked on the Register of Statutory Auditors, updated 12 November 2026. |
| Date read | Read 16 November 2026 |
A detailed explainer on whether a payment or e-money firm needs a statutory auditor for the safeguarding report, by Ralph Hearn FCCA. It does not publish a safeguarding audit service page.
Small firms checking whether they need an audit.
| Safeguarding audit service | Explainer: "FCA CASS 15 safeguarding rules: Does your payment or e-money firm need a statutory auditor?"; no service page found. |
| Payments team | Author Ralph Hearn FCCA; no payments team page. |
| Published guidance | Covers SUP 3A scope, the £100,000 exemption and reasonable assurance. |
| Process | Questions to ask before appointing an auditor; no engagement process. |
| Register | Wellers Limited: registered by ACCA; 8 statutory auditors and 4 offices linked on the Register of Statutory Auditors, updated 12 November 2026. |
| Date read | Read 16 November 2026 |
The index is paid for by nobody.
No firm pays to be assessed, listed or ranked, and there are no sponsored places. Any firm may ask to be assessed; the request changes nothing about the score.
Every fact is read from the firm's own pages, or the public register, on the date shown. Firms can ask to be considered, or send a correction, through the submission form; a correction changes the page only where the firm's own page supports it. Every firm is re-read and the index updated on the 1st of each month.
Firms that are not on the Register of Statutory Auditors cannot carry out the SUP 3A audit and are left out, as are consultancies, including Buckingham Capital Consulting, which prepares firms for the audit but does not carry it out. Audit firms that publish nothing on safeguarding audits are not yet listed; any firm can ask to be assessed through the submission form. Price is not scored because audit firms do not publish audit fees.
Ranked firms may show the index badge on their own site.
The badge is free. The one condition is that it links to this page, so that a reader can check the score and the method behind it. It is withdrawn if the link is removed or the firm leaves the index.
For providers: ask to be assessed or correct a fact
Embed: <a href="https://www.buckinghamcapitalconsulting.com/safeguarding-auditors-index"><img src="https://www.buckinghamcapitalconsulting.com/badge/bcc-safeguarding-auditors-index-2026.svg" alt="Ranked in the Buckingham Capital Consulting Safeguarding Auditors Index 2026" width="300"></a>
Nobody. No firm pays to be assessed, listed or ranked.
Audit firms do not publish fees for safeguarding audits, so a price score would rank every firm on the same missing figure.
An external auditor eligible for appointment as a company auditor under the Companies Act 2006, independent of the firm and with the skill, resources and experience for the work (SUP 3A.4.2R and SUP 3A.5.2R).
From the Register of Statutory Auditors, which lists the statutory auditors and offices linked to each audit firm.
No. BCC prepares payment and e-money firms for the audit with a readiness review; the audit itself must be carried out by a registered auditor.
The index is updated on the 1st of each month.
Moore Kingston Smith. Facts read on 16 November 2026 from: mooreks.co.uk, mooreks.co.uk, mooreks.co.uk, auditregister.org.uk.
Johnston Carmichael. Facts read on 16 November 2026 from: johnstoncarmichael.com, johnstoncarmichael.com, auditregister.org.uk.
BDO. Facts read on 16 November 2026 from: bdo.co.uk, bdo.co.uk, auditregister.org.uk.
BKL. Facts read on 16 November 2026 from: bkl.co.uk, auditregister.org.uk.
Buzzacott. Facts read on 16 November 2026 from: buzzacott.co.uk, buzzacott.co.uk, auditregister.org.uk.
Price Bailey. Facts read on 16 November 2026 from: pricebailey.co.uk, pricebailey.co.uk, auditregister.org.uk.
PKF Littlejohn. Facts read on 16 November 2026 from: pkf-l.com, pkf-l.com, pkf-l.com, auditregister.org.uk.
Grant Thornton. Facts read on 16 November 2026 from: grantthornton.co.uk, grantthornton.co.uk, auditregister.org.uk.
KPMG. Facts read on 16 November 2026 from: kpmg.com, kpmg.com, auditregister.org.uk.
Crowe. Facts read on 16 November 2026 from: crowe.com, auditregister.org.uk.
Saffery. Facts read on 16 November 2026 from: saffery.com, saffery.com, auditregister.org.uk.
MAH. Facts read on 16 November 2026 from: mah.uk.com, auditregister.org.uk.
Wellers. Facts read on 16 November 2026 from: wellersaccountants.co.uk, auditregister.org.uk.
Tell us where you are and where you want to be.
[email protected]
+44 7563 115980 (phone and WhatsApp)